How I Grew My Substack from (Almost) Zero to 40K Annual Income in Just 12 Months
Part Two of Two: Eleven Urgent & Possibly Helpful Things I Have Learned About Building A Newsletter During My First Year On Substack
Wow, thank you for your enthusiastic responses to yesterday’s nuts-and-bolts Part One post of “How I Grew My Substack from (Almost) Zero to 40K Annual Income in Just 12 Months.” It really made my day.
To note, amidst the hundreds of grateful comments, a couple of readers objected to the “from zero to 40K” phrase in the headline because I had that (mostly defunct) email list of 600 and 30 supporters on Patreon. Also, three decades of professional experience. I see their point. I was not literally at “zero” in every way, and I sought to unpack that in great detail in yesterday’s post—that despite my lack of platform, I have worked for and acquired (I’m 55 years old!) an expertise and a focus and even a certain amount of authority in my field which in turn absolutely helped me to build Writing in the Dark. But in industry terms, my numbers represent no platform, and I did start with zero paid subscribers on Substack. To that end, I’ve changed the headline to say “Almost Zero.”
Now, for the more philosophical Part Two of the post—in the spirit of gratitude—the eleven most salient things I’ve learned since launching. In addition to being a Part Two to yesterday’s post, this is also a companion to my Eleven Urgent & Possibly Helpful Things I Have Learned About Writing From Reading Thousands of Manuscripts post of a year ago.
1. Be yourself. On Substack, as with elsewhere else, it helps immeasurably to be who you actually are, to let yourself be seen and heard for your true self, and, in that way, to write the newsletter that only you can write. What does that mean? To write the newsletter that only you can write? Well, only you can answer that. It is a question to dwell on, to enter into, to sit quietly (or fitfully) inside of until you feel your way to the answer. For me, being myself means a few things, which I’ll get to in a moment, right after I acknowledge what it doesn’t mean. It doesn’t mean having to write a highly personal, intimate, confessional Substack. Absolutely not (unless you want to, then go for it! Writing in the Dark is admittedly intimate). It does mean you will benefit from writing in your own voice and from your own unique, specialized perspective in a way that no one else ever could. No one but you. It’s your newsletter, after all, and only yours, even if you publish lots of guest essays and cross posts, etc. It’s still your newsletter, and your readers want to hear your voice. So, no matter your topic, you will want to warm it, shape it, angle and chisel it by writing in your own fiercely unique register, tone, and timbre. As I said yesterday, it can help to ask yourself, why are you writing this newsletter, with the emphasis on you.
2. Desire determines who you become. As Maria Popova wrote in the Marginalian, “It is by wanting that we orient ourselves in the world, by finding and following our private North Star that we walk the path of becoming.” The most successful Substacks seem almost universally to be those created by people with a blazing passion (or, at minimum, an insatiable curiosity) for the topic(s) they write about. In other words, they are fueled by desire to know, understand, illuminate, create, share, connect, etc., around a certain axis of ideas. This kind of passion and curiosity is palpable, infectious, and cannot be faked. I know that my own curious passion has helped Writing in the Dark grow quickly and well from almost nothing. This newsletter is fueled by my burning belief in the power of language as an agent of self-discovery, human relationship, deeper meaning, and collective transformation—and that energy, in turn, fuels readership. In a crowded arena, which Substack has become, passion stands out. Therefore, it helps to be writing about what you care most about.
The intersection of writing and teaching—that is, the probing of what makes good writing sing and sear and how we can achieve that in our own work, and how doing so makes us better and makes the world better—truly excites me. I knew from the jump that if I launched a Substack it would be writing about writing and building a writing community because that’s where my desires live—that’s what I’ve always wanted and what I still want.
And, by the way, I love every chance I can get to think and talk about desire, about wanting—the verb. I love wanting, the heat and the ache of it, and the way it works, in the end, to not only fuel our creative practice, but indeed to define our lives. I believe it is the wanting we must nurture, the flames of desire we must fan, in order to sustain our creative practice over time, even when it’s hard. Also to reignite our creative practice after a necessary period of rest. We have to want it and let ourselves feel—really feel—the vulnerability of that wanting. And it is profoundly vulnerable. Wanting is always vulnerable. Which is why we—especially women (but also many men)—learn to avoid it, on the false hope that doing so will protect us from pain of not getting. But it won’t. Walling ourselves off from wanting or dulling its ache with other distractions will only distance ourselves from ourselves, which may be the worst kind of suffering of all. It’s taken me a long time to find the framework—let alone the words—for this topic. And I’m still not there, so forgive my clumsiness as I attempt to interrogate a territory as vast and dangerous as desire. I’m speaking about desire in a broad, deep sense of the word, the sense of it found in the word’s Latin root—“desidus,” which means “away from a star.” I could not love that more: the idea of our desire being a longing for a star! Maria Popova wrote gorgeously about this in the Marginalian, which is where I first learned of the etymology of the word desire. As Octavia Butler writes:
All prayers are to Self
And, in one way or another,
All prayers are answered.
Pray,
But beware.
Your desires,
Whether or not you achieve them
Will determine who you become.
3. Alignment matters. Alignment for me means being clear and intentional about what I’m doing so that I can make intuitive decisions that make sense for my personal goals, rather than find myself reeling from the constant barrage of conflicting advice about what works or doesn’t work on Substack (or anywhere else). Instead of being buffeted about, I listen to my own instincts and experience when it comes to what to publish, how often to publish, how short or long to make my posts, which images to use (or even how much emphasis to place on images/design), and, finally, if and how to paywall posts and at what rate, etc. It’s not that I don’t read any advice or look to others for guidance. I do! As I wrote about yesterday. It’s just that I don’t get overwhelmed or confused when the guidance is contradictory (which it often is) because I know what my goals are, which helps me know which advice applies to me and which advice is more suited for a different kind of newsletter. I resonate with advice that seems aligned with creating a truly beautiful, valuable newsletter about writing and the writing life, where people can ignite or re-ignite a writing practice, learn new and powerful ways to bring themselves to the page, re-invigorate their relationship with language, and find real community. When I keep those goals in mind, I tend to know what feels right and am able to let go of what doesn’t make sense for me. I am also able to confidently amend past decisions as needed when things change. Alignment is crucial for sustaining a growth pattern without burning out or getting knocked around in the constant churn of “how to succeed.”
4. Give value. Give the best value you can every time, regardless of paywalls. Of course, value and money are often connected. But value is a far more important place to put your focus than paywalls (the questions around which seem to cause many people much angst). Some say give everything away for free, no paywalls—just have faith that if people value it, they’ll pay you. For some writers, like Heather Cox Richardson, this model is working exceedingly well. It’s also going beautifully for the genius creative writer
, who paywalls nothing and has more than 500 paid subscribers just based on the beauty of her work. Others paywall nearly everything, because they believe that at a certain point, writers should be paid for their work. For the wildly popular and brilliant , who writes The Hyphen, that model is working fantastically. So what is one to do? There’s only one answer, which is that you must do what makes sense for you and for your publication, and be clear on why it makes sense. As said in her post last week, not all writing is ready for prime time or about topics that people are readily willing to pay for. Which is fine. Also, not all art needs to be monetized! That’s also fine. And not everyone on Substack needs to be hustling to grow. It’s 100% perfectly fine to just … write and explore and enjoy and see what comes of it! Just be clear with yourself on what it is you’re doing here so that you don’t get tossed around in the waves of other people’s visions and ambitions. Be so clear you can feel the clarity right down into your bones. When you’re very clear on your goals for your newsletter, it becomes easier to know what to do with regard to paywalls and everything else, too, which in turn makes it easier—when it comes to advice—to take what’s useful and leave the rest. In the meantime … focus on ensuring that your newsletter offers something of real value to your readers. Value can be so many things. I love when people make me cry, and I love when they make me laugh. I love when really smart people educate me on topics I care about (I’ve already mentioned Heather Cox Richardson, but also, check out who writes the the fabulous and incisive , which offers intricate, informed writing on women’s health that’s well worth paying for, and I do, or Sari Botton’s fabulous Oldster, or Virginia Sole-Smith’s Burnt Toast, just for starters). I also love when people write in artful, untamed ways that make me gasp with envy and awe. A newsletter can be many things—but to attract readers, paid or free, it must have value.5. Embrace generosity. I’ve written about generosity before—To Have, Give All to All, or What It Means to Write (& Live) Generously. And I love the generosity of the literary community in general. Inspired by others, I seek to be the most generous writer and teacher I can be, including here on Substack. I recommend approaching your work with a spirit of generosity in all the ways you can—and that’s as much about how you interpret the work and actions of others (gratitude and a little benefit of the doubt can come in handy) as it is about what you do and offer. And another thing about generosity: make it genuine and try not to expect anything in return. For example, I like to link to beautiful published work not just from established writers but also from emerging writers in my craft posts, because it helps their careers and it’s inspiring for my readers and my students to study work from writers who have not yet “broken out.” For the same reason, I try to share exceptional Substack posts from emerging writers (among others), as well. It’s also good to reach out directly to writers whose work you love, and tell them so. Comment on their posts because you have something to say. Restack posts because you really want others to see them. Try not, on the other hand, to do these things with the thought of an “exchange,” with the idea that these other writers will “return the favor.” That way lies the path to counting and measuring and comparing and resentment. It’s better to promote the work of others simply because you’re an engaged reader and generous literary citizen. Although the favor economy will always be part of how things work—it’s inevitable—it’s more fun and less stressful when you try to operate from a place of real love and enthusiasm, without tracking for reciprocation. Also, when likes, comments, and shares become a naked commerce of trade rather than genuine interaction, it tends to show. So, give generously and from the heart and avoid transactionalism lest you undermine your credibility and weaken your word. Simply be generous because it feels better than being ungenerous. To have, give all to all.
6. Be brave. When I first founded Writing in the Dark: The School in 2012 and started registering for my first-ever week-long retreat (I had never even attended a retreat, let alone led one!), I had no idea if anyone would sign up (I described that unnerving experience in detail in an interview with Hippocampus a couple of years ago.) But the part that’s relevant now is how my friend said to me, when she saw my retreat promos on Facebook, that I was very brave. “Well, I haven’t really invested any money or anything,” I told her. “My deposit for the lodging is totally refundable if no one registers. There’s not much at stake.” My friend nodded, then said softly that it wasn’t money she was talking about, it was the possibility of me putting myself out there and failing. How that would look for me. What people would think. “Oh, yes, that,” I said. “I know, but oh well.” You see, by then, I’d already come to understand, even before I knew the name for the spotlight effect, that no one was paying as much attention to me as I might believe they are in my most self-conscious moments. I’d already made peace with the possibility of failing, which is what allowed me to offer that retreat in the first place. And by the way, it sold out. Being brave means different things to different people, but I think it almost always means being willing to try new things, make mistakes, and embrace failure. It really is okay to fail, I promise. Remind me to tell you about the time, many years ago, when I had a nonfiction book deal with Simon and Schuster and my cowriter and friend called me to tell me, after a call with her agent, who’d just spoken to our editor, “Jeannine, she hated it. I mean, she really hated it.” Guess who’d done most of the writing at that point? That’s right. I had. Anyway, the contract was killed and the book never happened. I share this to counterbalance the retreat story. Not every story of risking failure ends happily. But I am still here, still writing, still being brave. Ultimately, as you’ve heard before, courage is about letting ourselves be afraid and doing things anyway. I love that venn diagram meme that shows where the magic happens (far outside of our comfort zone). I remind myself of it all the time, and then I keep going.
7. Write beautifully. What it means to write beautifully will vary depending on the topic and genre of your newsletter. In some instances, beauty might simply mean writing that is clear, factual, easy to read, and high value. My genre is creative and literary, so I work hard to ensure that even in my teaching posts, even in posts like this one, I find a way, in at least one or two lines, to show what I mean when I say good writing. Not every post is going to be a literary masterpiece—I’m writing a newsletter, after all, and I publish 3 to 5 times a week. But I do strive to play with language and make it clear that I care about writing, writing that wrings you out and leaves you in a heap in the basin of that old porcelain farm sink where you once stood to rinse the sour milk from sippy cups, where you stared into space toward the end of another marriage, another life, the life of a previous self whose next chapters you will never know.
8. Allow for ease. In yesterday’s nuts and bolts post about how I grew this Substack, I strongly emphasized hard work. And that’s true. However, and this is a big however, it’s also true that I’ve allowed for ease in a lot of crucial ways. And allowing for ease has made this project sustainable and joyful (even if tiring) rather than just a chore. Ways in which I’ve allowed for ease are myriad. For one thing, I let myself be nerdy and write about things I love, which is easier than writing about whatever I think I “should” be writing about. Once when I was struggling with some family stress and couldn’t bear to write the Monday post, I wrote about injured beavers falling in love instead, and it was one of my post popular posts this fall. I also reject perfectionism and refuse to beat myself up over typos (I’m writing thousands of words a week and don’t have a copyeditor or a proofreader—there are going to be typos). I don’t get too bound up over the appearance of the newsletter. I try, but only so much. Maybe later, I’ll be able to give more attention to the visuals. In my ideal world, I’d hire an artist illustrator. Maybe that day will come. For now, it’s good enough. And I guess for me that’s the central definition of “allowing for ease,” which is to say I don’t always have to set the bar beyond my own reach. That’s so mean. Making the thing unattainable for ourselves just creates frustration and a feeling of never being or doing enough, which leads to dis-ease. So I choose ease instead.
9. Make friends. We’re in the midst of an unprecedented epidemic of loneliness in America. It’s hurting our health and diminishing our spirits. So, yes, I could have said “build community,” but isn’t the idea of making friends more enticing? Some of my closest friends—almost all of them—are people I’ve met through writing and teaching. And aren’t friendships part of the connective tissue that holds community together? And isn’t it possible to make new friends at any age, and quickly? Why not? It’s what we’re here on Earth to do. I mentioned yesterday that I respond to comments, reply to emails, comment on and share other writers’ work, etc. And that’s all part of fostering a vibrant, engaged community of subscribers. But there’s so much more to literary community than “subscribers.” It’s about relationships and synergy. It’s about human connection, and the fragile threads that stretch between one life and another. I make a point of reaching out to other writers via email to ask about deeper collaborations or to express my awe when their work deeply moves me. And I love when other writers reach out to me. We’re in this together and there’s a buoyancy and lightness in lifting each other up. Last week when the beloved writer and extraordinary literary citizen Gabe Hudson died, I paused to read everything that everyone posted about him, even though I did not know him personally. Why? In part to honor his life, and in part because I want to live in the way he did, wherein I try to be a friend to everyone and allow for friendship to happen with ease in all of my interactions. In
’s poignant posthumously published interview on Beyond with Gabe this week, he said:I am nothing if not a litany of the kindnesses that others have shown me: every great thing that has happened in my life is the result of someone’s kindness and generosity of spirit. Because I know how life-altering kindness can be, I try to pay it forward every chance I get.
That’s how community is built, yes, but more importantly, it’s how friendships are made. I’m here for that.
10. Be curious. As Einstein said, “The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing. One cannot help but be in awe when he contemplates the mysteries of eternity, of life, of the marvelous structure of reality. It is enough if one tries merely to comprehend a little of this mystery every day.”
If you’re intrigued about the workings of curiosity and the power of a question, consider consider this passage written by the daughter of the Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget:
Where does that little baby come from? I don’t know. Out of the wood. Are you dust before you are born? Are you nothing at all? Are you air? Babies don’t make themselves, they are air. Eggshells make themselves in hens. I think they are air too. Pipes, trees, eggshells, clouds. The door. They don’t make themselves. They have to be made. I think trees make themselves and suns too. In the sky they can easily make themselves. How is the sky made? I think they cut it out. It’s been painted.
And isn’t a newsletter community a wonderful place to ask questions, to be ravenously, endlessly, delightfully curious? About the things we write about, yes, and about how to develop and grow your newsletter, sure! But also about every little thing that makes the world turn, that makes you you and me me, every little crevice in which intersections occur within this world we all share, every little granular detail you notice on your way through the checkout lane at the grocery store when the person behind you is quietly sobbing and the rain hasn’t let up and your daughter still hasn’t returned your message and you’ve begun to wonder how it is that you landed here as a middle-aged woman with a cart full of disposable diapers and canned cat food neither of which are for you. Listen, curiosity is the root of empathy, and empathy, in turn, lends depth, complexity, and emotional resonance to our writing. It’s no wonder, then, that I was so moved by what Maria Popova of the Marginalian wrote recently when discussing George Saunders and his invocation for us to love the world more and have courage for uncertainty. Popova said:
Nothing, not one thing, hurts us more — or causes us to hurt others more — than our certainties. The stories we tell ourselves about the world and the foregone conclusions with which we cork the fount of possibility are the supreme downfall of our consciousness. They are also the inevitable cost of survival, of navigating a vast and complex reality most of which remains forever beyond our control and comprehension. And yet in our effort to parse the world, we sever ourselves from the full range of its beauty, tensing against the tenderness of life.
11. Be grateful & celebrate. This might be my favorite lesson, and it’s one I’m still learning and practicing, even now, as I share this celebratory Writing in the Dark birthday post of the most salient lessons I’ve learned over the past year. Did I hesitate before pouring my heart into a two-part missive on the growth of my own newsletter? I sure did. Posts like these can seem boastful, like “look at me!” ploys, like attention grabs—all of which are topics that’ve come up recently here in Substack Notes. I don’t want to be seen that way. No one does. On the other hand, this path we’ve chosen, that of living a creative life and, in my case and many others, supporting ourselves (or trying to) in creative fields, is arduous, lonely, and rife with rejection and disappointment. With heartbreak, even. It can be a bitter, demoralizing, and sometimes even dehumanizing journey, the journey of the artist, a paradoxical truth if ever there was one, since art itself is so life-giving, and in some ways more accessible than ever before. As
Love,
Jeannine
PS So thank you so much for celebrating this one-year milestone with me. I am so grateful, and I’m eager to celebrate your milestones, too.
PPS I can’t believe it, and I know I’m repeating myself, but Story Challenge starts tomorrow!! I can’t wait to meet you there! If you are not a paid subscriber, I hope you’ll consider becoming one. You can read more about the Story Challenge in the post below—it’s going to be a grand adventure.
This is How Literary Fiction Teaches Us to Be Human
A Few Words from Participants in Writing in the Dark’s Recent Essay Challenge Grateful to you and also the process which was difficult to trust over so many weeks. It was a profound experience for me. This space has been such a joy and a boon—thank you for creating it.
I love these so much, Jeannine. Yesterday’s article offered such valuable practical information and expansive inspiration. Today’s spoke to my heart.
My aspiration for Substack includes making money (I mean, in my dream scenario, it’d be my full-time gig!). But also, as you so beautifully weave in here, I and many others show up on the platform for other reasons—whether or not we’re also trying to get paid for our work. For example, I think so many of us in the recovery community consider writing on Substack part of our healing and a support in staying sober—I know I do.
Thank you again for your wisdom and generosity. You are indeed such a caring, wise teacher!
There were so many moments when I paused and thought, "I want to share this, and celebrate it, and just savor it" and then 2 minutes later I'd say the same thing about another moment. So wonderfully written.
Just a quick note to say thank you for writing this and for sharing so generously of yourself. I normally don't read Susbtacks until later in the day (I try to reserve my mornings to write), but when I saw your post had been published, I had to switch up my routine. It was well worth it.